Martin Weigert’s thoughts on the social web. And life.

 
« Back to blog

Why I'm thinking about switching from iPhone to Android

I love my iPhone 3G. Still, even after 1 1/2 years. For me it was and still is the best product I have ever bought, considering how it changed my life, made me more productive, connected, social and whatnot. In the lights of the launch of the Nexus One, I even saw it as a statement to own an iPhone, a statement for a competitive market and for a web/tech business with a variety of strong companies.

The weird thing though is that I don't really feel that I as an iPhone owner benefit from this competitive market. I realized this after seeing all the great new features the latest version of Android 2.2 offers. And this is what made me realize that I might give up on my "principle" of sticking to the iPhone.

So what is the key feature of Android 2.2 that convinced me?

I was about to buy a MiFi, such a nice little portable 3g router that you can carry with you wherever you go, and in case you ever need a WiFi signal you just put your 3g Sim card into the MiFi and there you go, a wireless network ready for you or others to connect. A MiFi costs 200+ Euro, some cheaper alternatives a little bit less.

Then I saw the Google I/O keynote and one of the features that was presented for the new Android edition was WiFi tethering. That's exactly what the MiFi does. So I could skip the MiFi and buy an Android instead.

Unlike the iPhone, each Android 2.2. device will let you create an ad hoc wireless network, which is perfect for accessing the web with another computer when you are on the go. Despite more than 150.000 iPhone apps, there is no app for WiFi tethering in the app store. The ones that existed have been removed. I assume Apple wants to keep good relationships with the operators, so that they could charge for USB tethering if they want to (as some operators in Germany do). I could jailbreak my iPhone, which would give me access to a WiFi tethering app. But in my eyes that should not be the way things work.

The possibility of WiFi tethering on Android and the lack of such a function on the iPhone made me realize that there is in fact something wrong with the Apple approach. As long as Android was an underdog, that didn't matter. But now with Android on the rise and a variety of smart phones with the Google OS on the market, it's getting more obvious. And it feels wrong for me to stick to a principle when this doesn't give me the benefits I would expect from it (competitive market should lead to more freedom for the customers).

But what if the next iPhone that will be launched in June comes with WiFi tethering? Or what if Apple is seeing the threat by Android and allows WiFi tethering apps to appear in the app store? Sure, that would make me think again about which phone/OS to go for. But then there is still another issue: I really want to buy a new phone this summer, and because of several reasons I want to get one without subscription and SIM lock. It's very unlikely that any of the operators here in Sweden will make that happen - at least not for a reasonable price.

The alternative is to get a Nexus One (or a HTC Desire) for about 500 Euro without subscription and without SIM lock...

I think it's pretty obvious why I suddenly have way more sympathy for Android.

Comments (11)

May 24, 2010
NiftyNorman said...
If you decide to switch to Android you should get a Nexus One.

While HTC has this nice Sense-GUI, it is not updating its phones (at least, not a reasonable pace). Nexus One owners already have 2.2, HTC Hero owners (like me) are still stuck with 1.5 (and I don't expect that to change anytime soon)

May 24, 2010
Martin Weigert said...
Yeah I think either Nexus One, HTC Desire or HTC Wildfire would be the best choice right now. The latter two probably will get Android 2.2 very soon.
May 24, 2010
Andreas Goeldi said...
The problem is not Apple, it's the operators. Apparently, the iPhone will offer tethering in OS 4.0 (which will be announced in early June), but it's not clear which operators will allow it at what price.

Google just announces some random technical feature and conveniently forgets to mention that the technical feature is not the bottleneck. It's open, so let the user figure it out... On the other hand, Apple markets products to "normal" people who don't have the patience to deal with this stuff.

It remains to be seen on which networks you will actually be able to use Android tethering (well, legally, anyway), but my prediction is that there won't be much of a difference between tethering on the iPhone and Android.

May 24, 2010
Martin Weigert said...
Yep, that's why I wrote "I assume Apple wants to keep good relationships with the operators, so that they could charge for USB tethering if they want to (as some operators in Germany do)."
Nevertheless, Google makes it easier for the users to actually use WiFi tethering. Even if there is the risk of operators trying to ban it. But what I'm wondering is if there is a technical possibility for operators to actually block traffic through the WiFi tethering feature? Or if the only thing they can do is to remove the feature from their branded Android OS... ?

But as I wrote: As long as the iPhone was the only serious player in this field, some limitations didn't matter since customers had no other choice or benchmark. Now, that has changed.

May 24, 2010
Martin Weigert said...
One more thing: I have a Telia subscription for my iPhone, and I can use unlimited USB tethering without any extra costs. So at least in my case, there doesn't seem to be any objections from my operator regarding tethering. The problem is that Apple made this decision on a global level. Which i can understand, but still, it feels limiting to me.

Long story short: I don't expect Telia to block WiFi tethering from Android, since they don't have a problem with iPhone USB tethering.

May 24, 2010
Thomas Hoppe said...
Palm's WebOS devices have the Mobile Hotspot App for months now. Easiest tethering ever! I use it sometimes in connection with my iPod touch.
May 24, 2010
Martin Weigert said...
Palm WebOS? What's that....?
Just kidding :) But good to know that Palm is offering WiFi tethering. Although as a single feature that's not enough for me to go for WebOS.
May 24, 2010
Thomas Hoppe said...
I got it. Just wanted to make clear that webOS got his official tethering support first :-)
By the way, O2 in Germany did officially allow tethering in their T&Cs. Would Apple have a partnership with them, his Steveness could allow tethering in Germany.
May 25, 2010
Arno Nyhm said...
i have both - since one year an iphone and since 3 weeks an Nexus One

the android is a little bit nicer, faster etc.

but the worst thing is not the device ... it is the android market.

such shitty (sometimes not ready) apps i never seen on the iphone appstore ...

so i use my iphone ... and sometimes the android just for the google functions: google maps, thats all

May 25, 2010
Martin Weigert said...
That doesn't sound too encouraging... And that's the advantage of the Apple approval process. As long as it only would be a quality check, I would be totally fine with it. Because then I would have my WiFi tethering app on the iPhone ;)
Jun 16, 2010
rob d said...
Android oder iPhone? iPhone oder Android?
Ist bestimmt das 10te Blog in dem ich diese Fragestellung lese..

Dabei kann die Antwort doch so einfach sein:

Nutzt du mehr Google-Services als du Apple-Produkte dein Eigen nennst, dann nimm Android. Ansonsten nimm das iPhone.
Alles eine Frage der Integration.

Leave a comment...