Martin Weigert's thoughts on the social web. And life.

 
« Back to blog

Ironically, Google+ achieves what Facebook failed to: Making people share with the public

One of the reasons people praise Google+ for are the alleged better tools to protect your privacy. But think about the following:

What does usually happen when you try to access a stranger's Facebook profile? In most cases, you don't see anything else than the profile photo, some basic information (if shared with the public) and the list of friends. Because most people on Facebook have closed their profiles for non-friends.

Now, compare that with accessing strangers' public Google+ profiles when being logged out of Google+ yourself. I have hardly seen a profile that didn't contain at least some status updates, comment discussions and other shared content, accessible for anybody.

Of course, the reason for that is that Google+ allows for very selective content sharing. You might publish a YouTube video with the sharing option "public", and a provocative statement about politics only with specific circles or people.

Nevertheless, the result is more public content on Google+ than on Facebook. Ironically, that's exactly what Facebook tried to achieve but failed because of a user and media back clash.

And I would be surprised if there won't be a lot of unintentionally sharing with the public on Google+ in the future. 

 

Comments (3)

Jul 03, 2011
wispli said...
This is an important point. I think Google should be more clear about what posting "public" means. I don't even see an easy possibility to share content with all circles _without_ opening it up to the whole world. Yes, you can configure your post to be shared with all your circles by manually adding each of them to your post, but then Google seems to send Emails to everyone that is in one of my circles and has not yet signed up with Google Plus. This seems to be a bit of an overkill to me - I surely don't want to spam my friends.
Jul 03, 2011
wispli said...
OK I just found the option to share with "My Circles" or "Extended Circles" (at the bottom of the combobox that is shown when posting stuff). These are the options I think most people are used to from using fb.
Jul 11, 2011
Someone said...
I totally noticed that, too! G+ seems like it will be more public than it was intended to be.

Leave a comment...